Garaudy R. The founding myths of israeli politics.pdf

(3364 KB) Pobierz
Roger
Garaudy
The
Founding
Myths
of
Israeli
Politics
[Source
of
the
text:
CODOH:
http://codoh.com/
©
1996
All
rights
reserved.}
Contents
Introduction
Part
I:
Theological
Myths
1.
The
Myth
of
the
"Promise":
Promised
Land
or
Conquered
Land?
a.
In
Contemporary
Christian
Exegesis
b.
In
the
Prophetic
Jewish
Exegesis
2.
The
Myth
of
the
"Chosen
People"
3.
The
Myth
of
Joshua:
Ethnic
Purification
Part
II:
The
Myths
of
the
20th
Century
1.
2.
3.
4.
The
Myth
of
Zionist
Antifascism
The
Myth
of
the
Justice
of
Nuremberg
The
Myth
of
the
Holocaust
The
Myth
of
"A
Land
Without
a
People
for
a
People
Without
a
Land"
Part
III:
The
Political
Use
of
the
Myth
1.
The
Israeli-Zionist
Lobby
in
the
United
States
2.
The
Israeli-Zionist
Lobby
in
France
3.
The
Myth
of
the
Israeli
Miracle:
The
External
Financing
of
Israel
Conclusion
Addendum:
Annex
1.
Letter
from
Abbe Pierre
to
Roger
Garaudy,
15
April,
1996
2.
Letter
from
Pastor
Roger
Parmentier
to
Roger
Garaudy,
11
May,
1996
3.
The
Cry
of
a
Deportee
by
Gaston
Pernot,
Doctor
ofLaw,
Commander
of
the
Legion
ofHonor,
Paris
("Le
Figaro,"
Friday,
May
3,
1996)
4.
Indignation
of
an
Israeli
Writer
by
Ari
Shavit/Haaretz/New
York
Times
Syndication
(Translated
from
Hebrew
in
"Liberation"
of
May
21,
1996.)
3
Right
to
Reply—A
Pamphlet
in
Response
to
Attacks
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
A
Reply
to
the
Media
Lynching
of
Abbe
Pierre
and
Roger
Garaudy
Machination
of
a
Lynching
The
Scorned
"Right
to
Reply"
The
Witch
Hunt
Struggle
Against
All
Fundamentalisms
The
Magic
Word
that
Kills
As
for
the
lies
instituted
at
Nuremberg
Then
what
do
I deny?
One
Goal:
Gag
Abbe
Pierre
and
Garaudy
Zionism
against
Israel
A
Very
Powerful
Lobby
in
the
United
States
A
Very
Powerful
Lobby
in
France
The
Nuremberg
Taboo:
An
Inverted
Dreyfus
Affair
A
"Litany
of
Hate"
A
Tribal
Reading
of
the
Bible
A
Prophetic
Reading:
Abbe
Pierre
Abrogate
the
Totalitarian
Gayssot
Law
In
Whose
Interest?
But
the
Truth
Bursts
Against
Darkness
4
Introduction
THIS
BOOK
IS
THE
HISTORY
OF
A
HERESY.
THROUGH
A
LITERAL
AND
SELECTIVE
reading
of
a
Revealed
Word,
it
makes
religion
into
a
political
tool
and
in
so
doing,
hallows
it.
This
heresy
is
a
fatal
disease
at
this
end
of
the
century,
one
that
I
already
defined
in
"Integrismes."
I
fought
Islamic
fundamentalism
in
"The
Greatness
and
decadence
ofIslam
"
at
the
risk
of
displeasing
those
who
did
not
like
me
to
say
it.
I
fought
Christian
fundamentalism
in
"Towards
a
war
ofreligion
"
at
the
risk
of
displeasing
those
who
don't
like
me
to
say:
"The
Christ
of
Paul
is
not
Jesus."
I
am
fighting
today
Jewish
fundamentalism
in
"The
Founding
Myths
ofIsraeli
Politics"
at
the
risk
of
attracting
the
thunder
of
those
Israeli-Zionists
who
did
not
like
Rabbi
Hirsch's
reminder:
"Zionism
wants
to
define
the
Jewish
people
as
a
national
entity
...
which
is
a
heresy."
SOURCE:
"WashingtonPost,"
October
3,
1978.
What
is
the
Zionism
that
I
denounced
(and
not
the
Jewish
people)
in
my
book?
It
has
often
defined
itself:
it
is
a
political
doctrine.
"Since
1896,
Zionism
refers
to
the
political
movement
founded
by Theodore
Herzl."
SOURCE:
Encyclopedia
of
Zionism
and
Israel.
"Herzl
Press."
New
York,
1971,
volume
2,
p.
1262.
This
is
a
nationalist
doctrine
which
was
not
bom
out
of
Judaism
but
out
of
the
European
nationalism
of
the
19th
century.
Herzl,
the
founder
of
political
Zionism,
did
not
claim
to
belong
to
a
religion:
"I
do
not
obey
a
religious
impulse."
SOURCE:
Th.
Herzl:
"Diaries.
Ed.
Victor
Gollancz,
1958.
"I
am
an
agnostic."
(p.
54)
He
was
not
interested in
the
"Holy
Land"
in
particular:
for
his
nationalist
objectives,
he
would
have
equally
accepted
Uganda
or
Tripoli,
Cyprus
or
Argentina,
Mozambique
or
the
Congo.
SOURCE;
Herzl,
Diaries
(passim).
But
in
the
face
of
the
opposition
of
his
Jewish
friends,
he
realized
the
importance
of
the
"Mighty
Legend"
(June
9,
1895),
Diaries
I,
p.
56)
as
"a
rallying
cry
of
irresistible
power."
SOURCE:
Herzl,
p.
45.
This
is
a
mobilizing
slogan
that
this
eminently
realistic
politician
could
not
ignore.
Transposing
this
"mighty
Legend"
of
the
"Return"
into
historical
reality,
he
declared:
5
Zgłoś jeśli naruszono regulamin