Hood D. J. S., ... Nowhere ... St. T. More’s Utopia, 2009.pdf

(7068 KB) Pobierz
A
place
called
'nowhere':
Towards
an
understanding
of
St.
Thomas
More's
'Utopia'
Hood,
David
James
Sarty
ProQuest
Dissertations
and
Theses;
2009;
ProQuest
Dissertations
&
Theses
Full
Text
pg.
n/a
u
Ottawa
L’Université
canadienne
Canada’s
university
Reproduced
with
permission
of
the
copyright
owner.
Further
reproduction
prohibited
without
permission.
FACULTÉ
DES
ÉTUDES
SUPÉRIEURES
ET
POSTOCTORALES
u
Ottawa
L’Université
canadienne
Canada’s
university
FACULTY
OF
GRADUATE
AND
POSDOCTORAL
STUDIES
David
Hood
ÂÜtEÜR'DËÎ^TÏÏÉÏÏÉ7^ÜTHdR07THESÏS
M.A.
(History)
GRADE/DEGREE
Department
of
History,
Faculty
of
Arts
FÂ"c"ÙLtÈ7ECÔLÊ7DEPÀRTËMËNT/"FÂC"ÜLfŸ7s"CHÔÔL7DÈ"PÂRTMËNT
“A
Place
Called
‘Nowhere’:
Towards
an
Understanding
of
St-Thomas
More’s
‘Utopia’”
TITRE
DE
LA
THESE
/
TITLE
OF
THESIS
Dr.
Mark
Jurdjevic
dïrêc
T
éür
7
dïrë
7
ctr
^
œ-DÎRECTÉÜ'R
(CÔ-DÎRÉCTRICE)
DE
LA
THESE
/
THESIS
CO-SUPERVISOR
EXAMINATEURS
(EXAMINATRICES)
DE
LA
THÈSE/THESIS
EXAMINERS
Dr.
Vasillis
Vourkoutiotis
Dr.
Richard
Connors
Gary
W.
Slater
Le
Doyen de
la
Faculté
des
études
supérieures
et
postdoctorales
/
Dean
of
the
Faculty
of
Graduate
and
Postdoctoral
Studies
Reproduced
with
permission
of
the
copyright
owner.
Further
reproduction
prohibited
without
permission.
“A
PLACE
CALLED
‘NOWHERE’:
TOWARDS
AN
UNDERSTANDING
OF
ST.
THOMAS
MORE’S
‘UTOPIA’”
By:
David
James
Sarty
Hood
Department
of
History
Faculty
of
Arts
University
of
Ottawa
©
David
James
Sarty
Hood,
Ottawa,
Canada,
2009
Reproduced
with
permission
of
the
copyright
owner.
Further
reproduction
prohibited
without
permission.
1*1
Library
and
Archives
Canada
Bibliothèque
et
Archives
Canada
Direction
du
Patrimoine
de l'édition
395,
rue
Wellington
Ottawa
ON
K1A
0N4
Canada
Yourfile
Votre
référence
ISBN:
978-0-494-61327-6
Ourfî/e
Notre
référence
ISBN:
978-0-494-61327-6
Published
Heritage
Branch
395
Wellington
Street
Ottawa
ON
K1A
0N4
Canada
NOTICE:
AVIS:
L’auteur
a
accordé
une licence
non
exclusive
permettant
à
la
Bibliothèque
et
Archives
Canada
de
reproduire,
publier,
archiver,
sauvegarder,
conserver,
transmettre
au
public
par
télécommunication
ou
par
l’Internet,
prêter,
distribuer
et
vendre
des
thèses
partout
dans
le
monde,
à
des
fins
commerciales
ou
autres,
sur
support
microforme,
papier,
électronique
et/ou
autres
formats.
The
author
has
granted
a
non­
exclusive
license
allowing
Library
and
Archives
Canada
to
reproduce,
publish,
archive, preserve,
conserve,
communicate
to
the
public
by
telecommunication
or
on
the
Internet,
loan,
distribute
and
sell
theses
worldwide,
for
commercial
or
non­
commercial
purposes,
in
microform,
paper,
electronic
and/or
any
other
formats.
The
author
retains
copyright
ownership
and
moral
rights
in
this
thesis.
Neither
the
thesis
nor
substantial
extracts
from
it
may
be
printed
or
otherwise
reproduced
without
the
author’s
permission.
L’auteur
conserve
la
propriété
du
droit
d’auteur
et
des
droits
moraux
qui
protège
cette
thèse.
Ni
la
thèse
ni
des
extraits
substantiels
de
celle-ci
ne
doivent
être
imprimés
ou
autrement
reproduits
sans
son
autorisation.
In
compliance
with
the
Canadian
Privacy
Act
some
supporting
forms
may
have
been
removed
from
this
thesis.
Conformément
à
la
loi
canadienne
sur
la
protection
de
la
vie
privée,
quelques
formulaires
secondaires
ont été
enlevés
de
cette
thèse.
While
these
forms
may
be
included
in
the
document
page
count,
their
removal
does
not
represent
any
loss
of
content
from
the
thesis.
Bien
que
ces
formulaires
aient
inclus
dans
la
pagination,
il
n’y
aura aucun
contenu
manquant.
M
Canada
Reproduced
with
permission
of
the
copyright
owner.
Further
reproduction
prohibited
without
permission.
ABSTRACT
Hood,
David
James
Sarty.
MA.
The
University
of
Ottawa.
2009.
“A
Place
Called
‘Nowhere’:
Towards
an
Understanding
of
St.
Thomas
More’s
‘Utopia’”.
Supervisor:
Dr.
Mark
Jurdjevic.
St.
Thomas
More’s
Utopia
has
been
the
subject
of
considerable
debate
over
the
past
75
years.
It
claims
to
be
concerned
with
the
‘best
state
of
a
commonwealth’,
but
how
is
it
concerned?
It
is
a
strange
little
book
that
records
a
fictional
dialogue
between
More,
his
friend
Peter
Giles,
and
a
very
impulsive
and
opinionated
traveler
named
Raphael
Hythloday.
Hythloday
has
recently
returned
from
a
voyage,
and
the
Utopia
is
mostly
taken
up
with
a
detailed
account
of
the
bizarre
customs,
laws,
and
rituals
of
a
people
he
encountered
in
a
place
called
Utopia.
Hythloday
praises
them
as
the
best
and
wisest
people.
More
remains
skeptical,
but
does
acknowledge
that
certain
of
the
Utopian
practices
have
merit.
The
reader
is
therefore
left
wondering
whether
More
created
this
fictional
commonwealth
to
provide
a
model
for
reform,
or
whether
he
created
it
as
a
satire.
This
thesis
has
sought
to
contribute
to
the
wealth
of
research
on
this
topic,
by
interpreting
the
enthusiasm
of
Hythloday
and
the
skepticism
of
More
as
evidence
that
More
did
not
intend
the
Utopia
to
be
taken
literally,
but
neither
did
he
intend
for
it
to
be
read
solely
as
satire.
He
meant
for
the
Utopia
to
be
a
springboard
for
discussion
and
debate.
He
meant
to
create
a
platform
to
address
issues
plaguing
European
commonwealths.
I
have
come
to
this
conclusion
by
interpreting
the
Utopia
within
its
historical and
literary
context.
In
this
thesis
I
examine
the
circumstances
of
the
Utopia
’s
publication
and
distribution;
the
intellectual
and
cultural
influences
of
Renaissance
England,
and
More’s
immediate
circumstances
in
the
year
1515
when
he
wrote
the
Utopia.
I
then
move
from
a
general
study
of
the
Utopia
to
a
more
concentrated
study
of
its
content
where
I
provide
a
character
analysis
of
More,
Giles
and
Hythloday.
I
also
examine
the
inconsistencies
inherent
within
the
pages
of
the
Utopia,
as
well
as
the
inconsistencies
that
existed
between
More’s
life
and
the
ideals
he
seemingly
espoused
within
Reproduced
with
permission
of
the
copyright
owner.
Further
reproduction
prohibited
without
permission.
Zgłoś jeśli naruszono regulamin